tarlhawk wrote:The post is about Penny...but the 12 million+ FT tag was concerning keeping Diggs in place for an extended 3 to 4 yr contract.
Stream Hawk wrote:Penny’s back at 1 year. Turned down more money elsewhere. LFG
https://twitter.com/rapsheet/status/150 ... 64321?s=21
Stream Hawk wrote:Penny’s back at 1 year. Turned down more money elsewhere. LFG
https://twitter.com/rapsheet/status/150 ... 64321?s=21
RiverDog wrote:
$5.75M is a good deal. Now, if he can just stay healthy!
Stream Hawk wrote:Penny’s back at 1 year. Turned down more money elsewhere. LFG
https://twitter.com/rapsheet/status/150 ... 64321?s=21
Aseahawkfan wrote:Penny’s back at 1 year. Turned down more money elsewhere. LFG
https://twitter.com/rapsheet/status/150 ... 64321?s=21
Hawktawk wrote:But I guess once the season is over and you analyze his statistics, they were great against some garbage teams and the Rams still held him down.
If several other teams offered more for him Id say they were OK with the stats.![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
He was the #1 remaining FA back on the board per PFF. He set a couple of NFL records. He helped Russ greatly recover his value in trade by running that offense to a level it hadn't seen in years with balance and explosion in both the run and pass game.
Every garbage team beats good teams all the time and nobody stopped him in that 6 week period but PC by giving more carries to Dee Jay vs the Rams than Penney. I think he had 10 carries, 3.9 average despite Russ refusing to sell the read or break the pocket at all most of the night since he was in check out mode that game. He checked back in for the last 2 games for the farewell tour.
Kind of like when Penney was healthy early in his career and PC chose Carson over a guy just as big but faster and more elusive who averaged 6.1YPC for his CAREER when getting over 10 carries. Penney himself said a while back that its really hard to function as a running back getting a carry here and there.
It seems to me vs AZ he didn't do much early and almost seemed to go off after Buda Baker gator rolled him and twisted his knee. I think he had 130 yards after that play and the way he grimaced when it happened I thought the injury bug had bit him again. Great backs are like that. The later in the game it gets the better. The dam breaks. I think Carroll mismanaged his career then he got hurt. But if he stays healthy he will prove his doubters very wrong. I'm excited for him to get his chance to be the man.
NorthHawk wrote:One year prove it deal. No long term commitment. We get to see if the last few games were just a flash in the pan or not.
Aseahawkfan wrote:
If several other teams offered more for him Id say they were OK with the stats.![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
He was the #1 remaining FA back on the board per PFF. He set a couple of NFL records. He helped Russ greatly recover his value in trade by running that offense to a level it hadn't seen in years with balance and explosion in both the run and pass game.
Every garbage team beats good teams all the time and nobody stopped him in that 6 week period but PC by giving more carries to Dee Jay vs the Rams than Penney. I think he had 10 carries, 3.9 average despite Russ refusing to sell the read or break the pocket at all most of the night since he was in check out mode that game. He checked back in for the last 2 games for the farewell tour.
Kind of like when Penney was healthy early in his career and PC chose Carson over a guy just as big but faster and more elusive who averaged 6.1YPC for his CAREER when getting over 10 carries. Penney himself said a while back that its really hard to function as a running back getting a carry here and there.
It seems to me vs AZ he didn't do much early and almost seemed to go off after Buda Baker gator rolled him and twisted his knee. I think he had 130 yards after that play and the way he grimaced when it happened I thought the injury bug had bit him again. Great backs are like that. The later in the game it gets the better. The dam breaks. I think Carroll mismanaged his career then he got hurt. But if he stays healthy he will prove his doubters very wrong. I'm excited for him to get his chance to be the man.
Great backs start strong and keep on going.
Oly wrote:Everything about that contract is a best-case scenario for the team. I'm excited to see what he can do next year.
Oly wrote:Everything about that contract is a best-case scenario for the team. I'm excited to see what he can do next year.
Hawktawk wrote:The fact he stayed and took less is really hard to believe . An honest kid who said he would do exactly what he did . It’s a major score for the team . I’d love to know who else was bidding .
tarlhawk wrote:The reason is only half as important as the actual re-signing (of Penny).
tarlhawk wrote:We missed out on T. Brown and perhaps even D. Brown but the upcoming draft holds promise when we've picked our share of free agency "targets"... Our 2022 QB will have a strong running game and a plethora of receiving targets to keep Defenses from stacking the box. Waldron has us headed in the right direction and Andy Dickerson has renewed purpose with the re-signing of Penny. The question remains on what version of Drew Lock do we get? Can our coaching exploit his strong traits and restore his QB confidence? Our defense seems to be in the process of renewal with heavy emphasis on the 3-4 alignment...making it stronger while using a couple strong draft picks on our o-line could provide a quick remedy from our recent losing season.
RiverDog wrote:Before we start blowing too many kisses at Penny, we don't know why he stayed, whether it was loyalty to his coaches, his teammates, or fans, whether he and/or his wife/gf/kids didn't want to leave friends and family, if they liked the area and didn't want to take up ice fishing in Minnesota or spend summers swatting mosquitos in the humidity in New Orleans, or if career wise he simply felt that a bird in the hand was worth two in the bush. For sure, it was a home town discount, but what it was that motivated him to give us one is something none of us know. He's not the first player to have opted to stay with his current team for less money than he could have gotten somewhere else.
And as far as his honesty goes, yes, it's nice to see it once in awhile. But keep in mind that a lot of people once lauded Russell Wilson and Pete Carroll for their honesty, too, and we all know how that turned out.
RiverDog wrote:Before we start blowing too many kisses at Penny, we don't know why he stayed, whether it was loyalty to his coaches, his teammates, or fans, whether he and/or his wife/gf/kids didn't want to leave friends and family, if they liked the area and didn't want to take up ice fishing in Minnesota or spend summers swatting mosquitos in the humidity in New Orleans, or if career wise he simply felt that a bird in the hand was worth two in the bush. For sure, it was a home town discount, but what it was that motivated him to give us one is something none of us know. He's not the first player to have opted to stay with his current team for less money than he could have gotten somewhere else.
And as far as his honesty goes, yes, it's nice to see it once in awhile. But keep in mind that a lot of people once lauded Russell Wilson and Pete Carroll for their honesty, too, and we all know how that turned out.
Aseahawkfan wrote:We don't even know what else he was offered. He didn't get offered stupid money, so that is good.
A one year 5.75 million dollar deal is a best case scenario for Seattle. I knew once recency bias had worn off, people would look at the entirety of his career and not just four or five great games to decide what to spend.
The number of great backs that weren't great before an injury, spent four years doing nearly nothing, had a serious injury, then came back in year four, had a great stretch of games near the end of the year, and then went on to a great career must be infinitesimal. I can't think of any off the top of my head. Maybe some old school football fans can think of it, but I can't.
I'm hoping for the best, but not expecting much as far as Penny goes. Be nice to see a guy suddenly blow up in year five, but I don't think I've seen it too much save for a handful of QBs who had better careers later or at least serviceable.
Hawktawk wrote:For his career Penney averages 6.1 yards per carry when given 10 or more carries .he had a couple 100 yards games sharing carries with Carson . He was misused as a rookie leading to stunted development a wildcard loss . He was ready to take Carson’s job till injury . His flash in the pan which was exactly the type of explosion and power and speed he’s always had when healthy was historic , nfl record setting . He’s coming back as the feature back . And nobody knows what he was offered except he and bus agent and the teams offering . There was far more interest in Penney in FA than Carson last year as I recall . Carson’s good healthy which is almost never . He really can’t carry Penney’s jock strap if both are healthy . If Penney’s healthy he’s going for 1500 yards and 10 TDs minimum next year . If he isn’t healthy oh well we paid him Carson money and got the same result . I never saw Carson outrun an all pro safety 4 or 5 times in a game . I’m exctatic.
RiverDog wrote:]For his career Penney averages 6.1 yards per carry when given 10 or more carries .he had a couple 100 yards games sharing carries with Carson . He was misused as a rookie leading to stunted development a wildcard loss . He was ready to take Carson’s job till injury . His flash in the pan which was exactly the type of explosion and power and speed he’s always had when healthy was historic , nfl record setting . He’s coming back as the feature back . And nobody knows what he was offered except he and bus agent and the teams offering . There was far more interest in Penney in FA than Carson last year as I recall . Carson’s good healthy which is almost never . He really can’t carry Penney’s jock strap if both are healthy . If Penney’s healthy he’s going for 1500 yards and 10 TDs minimum next year . If he isn’t healthy oh well we paid him Carson money and got the same result . I never saw Carson outrun an all pro safety 4 or 5 times in a game . I’m exctatic
Penny was ready to take Carson's job until injury? Carson can't carry Penny's jock strap when healthy? Says who? And Carson is never healthy, as if Penny has been? Where in the heck have you been these past 4 years?
The fact is that Penny looked awful in preseason last year, had 32 yards on 12 carries and was out played by Alex Collins. He's spent more time in the hot tub than he has on the playing field. If he was ready to take Carson's job as you claim he was, don't you think that we would have picked up his 5th year option? It would have been cheaper than what we signed him to this season. You're engaging in some serious revisionist history.
When healthy, Carson has always been the #1 back, both in the coaches eyes as well as the eye test. That's why they resigned him last season. He's the better all around back that can play on all 3 downs. That may have changed, especially in light of Carson's neck injury that has the potential of being a career ender, but the fact is that up until the last few games in 2021, Penny was widely considered a bust. The last few games of this season has given Penny a second chance and he may, indeed, have turned the corner, but please, quit talking him up as if he's the second coming of Jimmy Brown.
Hawktawk wrote:Once again. Reversing hyperbole . Let me rephrase . Penney should have started as a rookie and had clearly shown himself more explosive at the second level . He was taking carries away from Carson in late 2019 when he was injured 20 yards downfield by a shot to the knee on an explosive play . Since then I know the story ok ?
You point out 32 yards on 12 carries in the preseason. I point out anytime Penney gets 10 or more he averaged 6.1 for his CAREER . Had he been getting 20 plus carries a game in 2018 the history of the Seahawks might have been better than a wildcard flameout with Carson plodding along for 20 yards on 14 carries while the benchwarmer had 29 on 4 and one was a 7 yard loss and still averaged 7.9. Carroll blew it . He got it wrong . It took Penney a long tine to get healthy but now he’s the same guy Pete underestimated the first year and a hakt of his career . I’m glad he’s back . I hope we’re around to settle the argument .
NorthHawk wrote:I think they have to select a good RB this year.
We can't go into the season with a questionable QB, a RB that might be injured too much to play, another RB that has a history of coming up flat
and a couple of RBs that are good situationally and expect the Offense to be anywhere near effective. Couple that with at the moment an OL that
might have 2 new starting and inexperienced Tackles and it's a big gamble to head into the season.
RiverDog wrote:
I want to see us rebuild both lines first, but so long as we don't do something stupid and trade away draft picks for player, we should have enough capital to acquire one if the right player falls to us, but I don't feel it's a high enough priority where we need to spend a high pick on one. There's a lot of very serviceable running backs out there.
RiverDog wrote:
Please, stop with the spin! You do it with every player that ignites your fantasies, whether it be Geno, Tim Tebow, or Baker Mayfield, not only with the X's and O's, but you dramatize/rationalize their personal attributes as well. Geno driving 96 mph on a Seattle freeway, drunk and belligerent with the cops? No problem! At least it wasn't as bad as Richard Sherman. Penny signs a $5+M contract? What a decent, honest, genuinely great guy he is! We all know that you like Penny, and that's fine. But you don't have to heap on the bull$hit. We've all seen him play over the past 4 seasons.
Bottom line is that Penny will be competing with Cris Carson for the starting job, assuming both are healthy. I'm glad to have him back on a team friendly prove it contract. We'll see how it goes.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 51 guests