Neither one of us knows whether or not Pete has changed. I'm basing my opinion on this year's draft as it was a marked departure from the ones from the past 10 or so seasons. No trading down, no early reaches, emphasis on the OL and DL lines, didn't take a QB in a weak class. I always felt that Pete and John had a certain degree of arrogance about them, that they had their own, unique system, that the didn't need highly ranked players to make it work, that the system was better than the players in it. This draft seemed to indicate a change in their outlook, an admission that what they've been doing in the past wasn't working.
tarlhawk wrote:Its amazing some of the depth fans go to in being dismissive of a man seldom credited for the dramatic turnaround that this franchise has been experiencing since his arrival. Our team has a winning culture and you can hear it from a multitude of sources if you bother to listen. Recently Sean Desai via media conference said he was curious if all the winning culture talk surrounding Pete Carroll was real or slightly fabricated...but upon arrival and first coaching "get together" he found it very real and representative of Pete's reputation as a winning coach. Even our invited female coach who is here courtesy of an NFL program named after Bill Walsh was gushing with retelling her first impression and talk with Pete. An atmosphere which fosters bringing out the best in talent is highly valued by players and coaches alike but apparently some fans "know better" or at least express themselves that way.
RiverDog wrote:So specifically, just who is it that 'amazes' you ...but I'm beginning to detect a bit of arrogance in your remarks.
This is an opinion forum. We are expressing our various points of view, nothing more, nothing less. It should not be interpreted as 'knowing more' than the head coach, GM, owner, etc.
RiverDog wrote:So River are you saying Jodi should have fired PC and brought back Russ with a new young offensive minded coach? After having heard all the backstory about feuding, checking out?
Yes, I think Jody should have fired Pete, and done so before the end of the regular season. As far as Russell having 'checked out', that's your opinion based on a cherry picked, truncated quote that also said that Pete was equally to blame.
tarlhawk wrote:So specifically, just who is it that 'amazes' you ...but I'm beginning to detect a bit of arrogance in your remarks.
This is an opinion forum. We are expressing our various points of view, nothing more, nothing less. It should not be interpreted as 'knowing more' than the head coach, GM, owner, etc.
It shouldn't be interpreted as arrogance to appreciate the work of a coach to the point where I'll take exception to "those" who target him as some problem that the team must be "rid of". I did not address an individual because there are many...not just on this site. I did not profess those I have targeted in my remarks as "knowing better" than the Coach...but knowing better of when management should just go away.
I don't like attack postings so I'll apologize for any I quickly offended. I respect opinion as well...I've just been caught up by watching recent videos increasing my favorable opinion of the man burdened with the responsibility of keeping our football team relevant. Sorry Riv if it was your post that "triggered" my opinion of many...not you personally.
RiverDog wrote:So River are you saying Jodi should have fired PC and brought back Russ with a new young offensive minded coach? After having heard all the backstory about feuding, checking out?
Yes, I think Jody should have fired Pete, and done so before the end of the regular season. As far as Russell having 'checked out', that's your opinion based on a cherry picked, truncated quote that also said that Pete was equally to blame.
Hawktawk wrote:Cherry picked. It’s always your comeback when it doesn’t match your narrative this week.
tarlhawk wrote:Its amazing some of the depth fans go to in being dismissive of a man seldom credited for the dramatic turnaround that this franchise has been experiencing since his arrival. Our team has a winning culture and you can hear it from a multitude of sources if you bother to listen. Recently Sean Desai via media conference said he was curious if all the winning culture talk surrounding Pete Carroll was real or slightly fabricated...but upon arrival and first coaching "get together" he found it very real and representative of Pete's reputation as a winning coach. Even our invited female coach who is here courtesy of an NFL program named after Bill Walsh was gushing with retelling her first impression and talk with Pete. An atmosphere which fosters bringing out the best in talent is highly valued by players and coaches alike but apparently some fans "know better" or at least express themselves that way.
RiverDog wrote:Neither one of us knows whether or not Pete has changed. I'm basing my opinion on this year's draft as it was a marked departure from the ones from the past 10 or so seasons. No trading down, no early reaches, emphasis on the OL and DL lines, didn't take a QB in a weak class. I always felt that Pete and John had a certain degree of arrogance about them, that they had their own, unique system, that the didn't need highly ranked players to make it work, that the system was better than the players in it. This draft seemed to indicate a change in their outlook, an admission that what they've been doing in the past wasn't working.
Aseahawkfan wrote:Be nice if you took equal umbrage with attacks on Russell Wilson as you did on Pete Carroll. As tired as you are of hearing that about Carroll, I'm that tired of hearing it about Russell Wilson, mainly from one poster who seems to have had some kind of mental break with Russell being traded and now feels it's his mission to convince everyone Russell was the bad guy, Russell is all washed up and checked out, and Russell is the Devil. It's super tiresome and annoying just like listening to people question Carroll.
RiverDog wrote: So River are you saying Jodi should have fired PC and brought back Russ with a new young offensive minded coach? After having heard all the backstory about feuding, checking out?
Yes, I think Jody should have fired Pete, and done so before the end of the regular season. As far as Russell having 'checked out', that's your opinion based on a cherry picked, truncated quote that also said that Pete was equally to blame.
Cherry picked. It’s always your comeback when it doesn’t match your narrative this week.
Aseahawkfan wrote:Be nice if you took equal umbrage with attacks on Russell Wilson as you did on Pete Carroll. As tired as you are of hearing that about Carroll, I'm that tired of hearing it about Russell Wilson, mainly from one poster who seems to have had some kind of mental break with Russell being traded and now feels it's his mission to convince everyone Russell was the bad guy, Russell is all washed up and checked out, and Russell is the Devil. It's super tiresome and annoying just like listening to people question Carroll.
tarlhawk wrote:Not sure if you were aware of my earlier posts when Russell was very much a part of our future...I defended and talked about my strong disbelief that RW would leave us...but Russell is gone and Pete remains. Each of them benefited from the other and sadly that golden partnership has ended. Both men are strong enough going forward to add to their HOF resumes. I sincerely wished we hadn't lost Russell (who gave me as a fan many exciting moments in time) but other than wishing him well I tend to focus on what remains. Russell doesn't need defending...I think life and his iron man confidence took a toll during 2021...if his confidence returns he'll be just as important to his new team... as the talent infusion we received from his loss ...will be important to our team as a whole.
Hawktawk wrote:It’s true or it isn’t . I believe it based on many other factors as well that I’ve already discussed.
tarlhawk wrote:Be nice if you took equal umbrage with attacks on Russell Wilson as you did on Pete Carroll. As tired as you are of hearing that about Carroll, I'm that tired of hearing it about Russell Wilson, mainly from one poster who seems to have had some kind of mental break with Russell being traded and now feels it's his mission to convince everyone Russell was the bad guy, Russell is all washed up and checked out, and Russell is the Devil. It's super tiresome and annoying just like listening to people question Carroll.
Not sure if you were aware of my earlier posts when Russell was very much a part of our future...I defended and talked about my strong disbelief that RW would leave us...but Russell is gone and Pete remains. Each of them benefited from the other and sadly that golden partnership has ended. Both men are strong enough going forward to add to their HOF resumes. I sincerely wished we hadn't lost Russell (who gave me as a fan many exciting moments in time) but other than wishing him well I tend to focus on what remains. Russell doesn't need defending...I think life and his iron man confidence took a toll during 2021...if his confidence returns he'll be just as important to his new team... as the talent infusion we received from his loss ...will be important to our team as a whole.
NorthHawk wrote:They didn't part with a lot of animosity.
It was simply a difference in philosophies going forward.
Russ wanted a 2022 Offense and Pete wants a 1970s Offense. Those two things can't mesh.
From the reports I read, Russ didn't "check out". He was the same guy every day every year but he saw his future wasn't playing for Carroll.
That's all there is to it.
NorthHawk wrote:They didn't part with a lot of animosity.
It was simply a difference in philosophies going forward.
Russ wanted a 2022 Offense and Pete wants a 1970s Offense. Those two things can't mesh.
From the reports I read, Russ didn't "check out". He was the same guy every day every year but he saw his future wasn't playing for Carroll.
That's all there is to it.
Hawktawk wrote:The Eagles were the only team with less attempts between the hashes and Genos 13 quarters using the middle of the field constantly is what pulled us out of the cellar. That's not the Waldron offense. Russ runs the Russel Wilson offense. Good luck Hackett.
What does a 2022 offense look like? What exactly are they doing? I haven't noticed them scoring more points than Pete's 1970s offense. The Rams weren't exactly putting up more points or even yards most years than Seattle.
I'm not sure what you mean by this or if you could even really prove it.
RiverDog wrote:So specifically, just who is it that 'amazes' you ...but I'm beginning to detect a bit of arrogance in your remarks.
This is an opinion forum. We are expressing our various points of view, nothing more, nothing less. It should not be interpreted as 'knowing more' than the head coach, GM, owner, etc.
tarlhawk wrote:It shouldn't be interpreted as arrogance to appreciate the work of a coach to the point where I'll take exception to "those" who target him as some problem that the team must be "rid of". I did not address an individual because there are many...not just on this site. I did not profess those I have targeted in my remarks as "knowing better" than the Coach...but knowing better of when management should just go away.
I don't like attack postings so I'll apologize for any I quickly offended. I respect opinion as well...I've just been caught up by watching recent videos increasing my favorable opinion of the man burdened with the responsibility of keeping our football team relevant. Sorry Riv if it was your post that "triggered" my opinion of many...not you personally.
Aseahawkfan wrote:The Eagles were the only team with less attempts between the hashes and Genos 13 quarters using the middle of the field constantly is what pulled us out of the cellar. That's not the Waldron offense. Russ runs the Russel Wilson offense. Good luck Hackett.
I have no idea why you think Russell runs whatever offense he feels like running. Stupidest idea I've ever heard. Russ is about as by the book as a QB comes in the NFL. He was running Pete's offense for ten years, not something he made up. Yet you don't want to admit that. This is all Pete's offense and defense. Always has been, always will be.
Old but Slow wrote:Hatred of Geno? That is a bit extreme. While I do not think he is likely to be a quality starter, there is no doubt that he can be a valuable #2. And, I am not sure that Lock is any better. I hope he is, but I have doubts.
In my view we have two QBs capable of holding down the fort until we can find a long term answer.
I have not seen anything to indicate "hate" for Geno. Perhaps a lack of love would be closer.
Old but Slow wrote:Hatred of Geno? That is a bit extreme. While I do not think he is likely to be a quality starter, there is no doubt that he can be a valuable #2. And, I am not sure that Lock is any better. I hope he is, but I have doubts.
In my view we have two QBs capable of holding down the fort until we can find a long term answer.
I have not seen anything to indicate "hate" for Geno. Perhaps a lack of love would be closer.
Yeah, no one 'hates' Geno. The term is one of the most misused in the English language. Lack of respect is a lot more appropriate way to describe most fans' sentiment. His main value is that he knows the system and the other players. It's tough on everyone when there isn't an experienced signal caller to run the show as many times, their progress is directly dependent on the play of the quarterback. I'm not sure that Geno would have had a job had it not been for the Russell trade. We were awfully late resigning him, over a month after the Wilson trade.
As far as Lock goes, yes, it is possible that a change of scenery will resurrect his once promising career. It doesn't happen often, but that doesn't mean that it can't. Like Geno, he's going to have to clean up his turnovers if we are to have a shot at even a .500 season, something that could end up being a real challenge if we start two rookie bookends as is the apparent plan.
So we'll see. I'm approaching this season with more curiosity than excitement.
RiverDog wrote: Hatred of Geno? That is a bit extreme. While I do not think he is likely to be a quality starter, there is no doubt that he can be a valuable #2. And, I am not sure that Lock is any better. I hope he is, but I have doubts.
In my view we have two QBs capable of holding down the fort until we can find a long term answer.
I have not seen anything to indicate "hate" for Geno. Perhaps a lack of love would be closer.
Yeah, no one 'hates' Geno. The term is one of the most misused in the English language. Lack of respect is a lot more appropriate way to describe most fans' sentiment. His main value is that he knows the system and the other players. It's tough on everyone when there isn't an experienced signal caller to run the show as many times, their progress is directly dependent on the play of the quarterback. I'm not sure that Geno would have had a job had it not been for the Russell trade. We were awfully late resigning him, over a month after the Wilson trade.
As far as Lock goes, yes, it is possible that a change of scenery will resurrect his once promising career. It doesn't happen often, but that doesn't mean that it can't. Like Geno, he's going to have to clean up his turnovers if we are to have a shot at even a .500 season, something that could end up being a real challenge if we start two rookie bookends as is the apparent plan.
So we'll see. I'm approaching this season with more curiosity than excitement.
Hawktawk wrote:I’m going on memory but I think PC stated a desire to bring Geno back a while before Russ was traded.
Hawktawk wrote:I think lots hate the thought of him (Geno) starting as Russel Wilson’s successor.
Hawktawk wrote:I’m going on memory but I think PC stated a desire to bring Geno back a while before Russ was traded . I was surprised at the time after this messy DUI that’s yet to be resolved . The delay in the end was Geno holding out for a better deal which Pete publicly appealed to him to sign .
After Russ was traded it began to make more sense to me . I’m overly hyperbole centric on the forum
and “ hate “ in this context is meant as an internet gaslight .
I think lots hate the thought of him starting as Russel Wilson’s successor .
But actual hate ? Of course not . Nor do I “hate “ Russ . I definitely hate how his career ended here , I don’t understand why he’s continuing to fixate on who decided on the trade while saying he wants to go to a city that wants to win and knows how. And made the comments in front of a bunch of kids at a football camp .
If Russ goes there and really pulls it off meaning a championship I’ll tip a cap to him . I’ll cheer when he goes in the hall . How soon will depend on what he does now. But I may not hate the guy but I sure don’t like him nearly as much after this saga.
Until proven otherwise I will trust that we are in “ good shape at the position .” That’s what really matters . Because Pete didn’t come back to be a terrible team , lose a ten year argument and get canned in a year anyway . He’s got the fire burning brighter than in some time I suspect .
RiverDog wrote:I’m going on memory but I think PC stated a desire to bring Geno back a while before Russ was traded.
Do you mean the same PC that said they weren't planning on trading Russell? Or is there some other person with the initials 'PC" that you're talking about?
For the umpteenth time, you have to take what Pete says with a grain of salt, especially when he says something so non definitive as "expressing a desire."
I think lots hate the thought of him (Geno) starting as Russel Wilson’s successor.
After the statements Geno made to the cops after his DUI arrest, I lost a lot of respect for him, so on a strictly personal level, I don't want him even associated with our team, not to mention being the 'face of the franchise' starting quarterback, at least until he comes forward with some sort of apology or reasonable explanation, of which I have yet to hear.
I recognize that it was just one incident, so I've tried not to be too judgmental. But it's quite a change from Russell, who personality and character wise was as good as they come.
Hawktawk wrote:Jesus River. Buddy. He said he wanted him back and he took him back so I think he was telling the truth there. Good lord![]()
.
Wyman is in your camp, having argued on air with the late John Clayton that Geno might be starter material ( nobody expected a job opening here at the time) to now saying hell no strictly based on the DUI. He said it shows a lack of maturity . How many does Warren Moon have now? I have a nuanced position here. For one I've had a DUI along with millions of Americans in a land with legal alcohol;, restrictions on police oversight and a bar on every corner. I did not behave that way with cops at all but i know those who did including a high school friend who wound up getting himself yanked out of the t top of his trans am by a 6;9' 300 lb trooper for refusing to exit his vehicle. I dont like what Geno did but weve had guys who beat women , Lynch wasn't a choir boy with a hit and run on a pedestrian in buffalo that likely involved being drunk but he drove off. I dont find it disqualifying at this point in this day and age .
And I know I'm wading into another broadside but I find not honoring a contract a bit of a character flaw too. Splitting words to win a PR battle while being completely disingenuous. Extreme narcissism is a character flaw. Doesn't mean someone cant be a terrific QB obviously. But it might be more disruptive to team chemistry than a dude that got dunk and drove one night. But Im done with comparing characters here, more so all the time. I prefer a genuine person.
Hawktawk wrote:But Im done with comparing characters here....
RiverDog wrote:Jesus River. Buddy. He said he wanted him back and he took him back so I think he was telling the truth there. Good lord![]()
.
Wyman is in your camp, having argued on air with the late John Clayton that Geno might be starter material ( nobody expected a job opening here at the time) to now saying hell no strictly based on the DUI. He said it shows a lack of maturity . How many does Warren Moon have now? I have a nuanced position here. For one I've had a DUI along with millions of Americans in a land with legal alcohol;, restrictions on police oversight and a bar on every corner. I did not behave that way with cops at all but i know those who did including a high school friend who wound up getting himself yanked out of the t top of his trans am by a 6;9' 300 lb trooper for refusing to exit his vehicle. I dont like what Geno did but weve had guys who beat women , Lynch wasn't a choir boy with a hit and run on a pedestrian in buffalo that likely involved being drunk but he drove off. I dont find it disqualifying at this point in this day and age .
And I know I'm wading into another broadside but I find not honoring a contract a bit of a character flaw too. Splitting words to win a PR battle while being completely disingenuous. Extreme narcissism is a character flaw. Doesn't mean someone cant be a terrific QB obviously. But it might be more disruptive to team chemistry than a dude that got dunk and drove one night. But Im done with comparing characters here, more so all the time. I prefer a genuine person.
Hawktawk wrote:But Im done with comparing characters here....
Yeah, we've heard that before. Didn't you once make a promise not to talk about Russell until 9/12? Why can't you just accept the fact that he's no longer our quarterback and move on? You keep comparing him to others, keep re-iterating how bad he's been since mid 2020, telling us that he has "extreme narcissism", starting threads about quotes he's made as a Bronco, telling us all about how he's going to flop, and on, and on, and on. You're tiresome.
Hawktawk wrote:Geno "was" an Ahole while intoxicated . Obviously he cant say anything now till his case is resolved. And you strike me as a guy who has never said or done anything anyone would call A hole behavior. I know I'm guilty. Geno can start for me.
RiverDog wrote:Geno "was" an Ahole while intoxicated . Obviously he cant say anything now till his case is resolved. And you strike me as a guy who has never said or done anything anyone would call A hole behavior. I know I'm guilty. Geno can start for me.
There are two types of drunks: Happy drunks and mean drunks. I'm a happy drunk. That doesn't mean that I've never acted in a manner that I was embarrassed of, but I've always strived to self assess my actions/behavior, admit to my faults, and when I feel appropriate, apologize for my human flaws.
The unresolved legal status of Geno's DUI does not prevent him from issuing a statement apologizing for his behavior, indeed, it might show the prosecutor that he is remorseful of the event and could win him some consideration for leniency. He doesn't have to admit to how much he had to drink, where he had been, what kind of drugs he'd been taking, etc, information that might negatively affect the outcome of his case, in order to issue an apology if he felt he owed one. People do it all the time, and do so before the start of any legal action.
Being drunk isn't an excuse for unacceptable behavior. Indeed, being drunk might in some cases expose a true personality, act as a truth serum. Geno strikes me as a mean drunk, and I stand by my assessment of him as an A-hole until I see some other information that might cause me to re-evaluate my opinion of him.
The longer Geno waits to explain or apologize, the more it will appear to be a calculated remark designed to enhance his image rather than a genuine feeling of remorse for those he may have insulted.
I have not called for Pete's firing or resignation since the end of the season. I have accepted the fact that he's our coach going forward. I have not given him a pass for 2022, but I will have an open mind about his performance as the season progresses. Indeed, I have expressed satisfaction with his recent draft. That doesn't mean that I won't say negative things about him. It's an opinion forum, not a fanboy club. Pete's the current head coach of our team, quite unlike Russell, who is now a former quarterback that used to play for us and plays for a team not even in the same conference as us.
RiverDog wrote:Geno made a dumb mistake then compounded it by insulting people that were simply doing their jobs and has failed to acknowledge that he was wrong for having done so. That makes him an A-hole in my book.
Hawktawk wrote:My arresting officer cranked my cuffs so tight my left hand went numb . About went to my knees . I Informed him it was too tight immediately and he chuckled and smiled and walked away . My hand was numb for 4 months . And I was compliant to a fault , non threatening . Polite . At least Geno had the excuse of being drunk when acting like a Jackass . What’s that cops excuse for hurting me ? I’m big , probably outweighed him by 75 lbs. maybe he was afraid of me. But that’s an Ahole maybe worse then Geno I don’t give a good god damn what happened and what the cops reieased served their narrative , count on it .
If he can play he can start for my team
Hawktawk wrote:My arresting officer cranked my cuffs so tight my left hand went numb . About went to my knees . I Informed him it was too tight immediately and he chuckled and smiled and walked away . My hand was numb for 4 months . And I was compliant to a fault , non threatening . Polite . At least Geno had the excuse of being drunk when acting like a Jackass . What’s that cops excuse for hurting me ? I’m big , probably outweighed him by 75 lbs. maybe he was afraid of me. But that’s an Ahole maybe worse then Geno I don’t give a good god damn what happened and what the cops reieased served their narrative , count on it .
If he can play he can start for my team
Aseahawkfan wrote:Unless his name is Russell Wilson and you spend post after post making him like some kind of terrible person, while you make excuses for guys getting DUIs.
Aseahawkfan wrote:My arresting officer cranked my cuffs so tight my left hand went numb . About went to my knees . I Informed him it was too tight immediately and he chuckled and smiled and walked away . My hand was numb for 4 months . And I was compliant to a fault , non threatening . Polite . At least Geno had the excuse of being drunk when acting like a Jackass . What’s that cops excuse for hurting me ? I’m big , probably outweighed him by 75 lbs. maybe he was afraid of me. But that’s an Ahole maybe worse then Geno I don’t give a good god damn what happened and what the cops reieased served their narrative , count on it .
If he can play he can start for my team
Unless his name is Russell Wilson and you spend post after post making him like some kind of terrible person, while you make excuses for guys getting DUIs.
RiverDog wrote:My arresting officer cranked my cuffs so tight my left hand went numb . About went to my knees . I Informed him it was too tight immediately and he chuckled and smiled and walked away . My hand was numb for 4 months . And I was compliant to a fault , non threatening . Polite . At least Geno had the excuse of being drunk when acting like a Jackass . What’s that cops excuse for hurting me ? I’m big , probably outweighed him by 75 lbs. maybe he was afraid of me. But that’s an Ahole maybe worse then Geno I don’t give a good god damn what happened and what the cops reieased served their narrative , count on it .
If he can play he can start for my team
Unless his name is Russell Wilson and you spend post after post making him like some kind of terrible person, while you make excuses for guys getting DUIs.
Yeah, I fail to see how HT's experience with being arrested has anything to do with Geno's DUI.
Geno can play for my team, too. I've just lost a lot of respect for him personally, and haven't seen anything out of him that would cause me to change my mind.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 45 guests