RiverDog wrote:I swear, some people just can't think independently. They take a position on a subject based on their very general liberal or conservative ideology regardless of its merits.
I agree with your thoughts on economics, but the point of my argument is that tariffs do hurt an economy, healthy or otherwise, the only question being to what degree. Idahawk and the Trumpies are trying to tell us that they have no effect AT ALL. It's no different than raising taxes. You're taking money out of the hands of the consumer and putting it into the government's coffer. They also support outdated, poorly managed companies by giving them a competitive advantage. We're better off letting those industries go extinct, let China or India make our raw materials for us, and dedicate our limited investment capital to an industry that can sustain itself without the benefit of tariffs.
That's been my big problem with Trump's tariffs, that he's supporting the wrong industries. There's not that many jobs to be gained in steel and aluminum and he's hurting other companies that depend on a cheap source of raw materials to maintain their competitive advantage. Besides, we don't have a problem with a lack of jobs.
First, the problem I am encouraging you to take a look at is a time bomb. It requires an understanding of economics that you don't seem to be grasping as you focus on a short-term issue like tariffs.
https://www.marketwatch.com/story/us-consumer-debt-is-now-breaching-levels-last-reached-during-the-2008-financial-crisis-2019-06-19 It's got that roaring twenties, the good times will never end feel to it.
These tariffs will last as long as Trump. The money being shunted into government coffers might even be helpful given the government shortfalls. We have major spending shortfalls not being covered by the moderate increase in economic growth and wages. You could also argue that the farmers being damaged by tariffs are also outdated and inefficient. American steel is not outdated and inefficient, it is more a matter of wage levels being much higher in America. It is much more cost efficient from a labor standpoint to process materials in other nations other than maintaining a large enough industry to ramp up for national security reasons. Our technology or efficiency has nothing to with why manufacturing is gone from Western nations. It's almost purely based on the cost of labor in foreign nations with corporations looking to exploit weaker labor laws and much lower wages to produce at a much lower cost.
We have a far longer term, more dangerous issue with the debt that is ticking away. You just don't get how bad this is and won't get it until it hits. The low interest rates with the building equity bubble and slowing growth is the same kind of economic disaster recipe that has occurred multiple times in the last twenty years. You are focused on a tariff issue that is a short-term problem that isn't even close to the danger of the growing leverage bubble. It's in fact a minor blip on the radar compared to the leveraging going on right now.
I'm focused on the leverage problem because its effect on the economy far exceeds any damage or benefit based on tariffs. It's going to hit us hard again and create another immense wealth transfer like we've been seeing. You don't follow financial information like I do thus your focus on a popular political topic like tariffs that ties into economics. I can't spend much time focusing on a short-term, easily fixed problem like tariffs while I'm watching a level of leverage building up that is going to hammer not only America, but the world economy. World interest rates are so low there is literally nowhere else to earn much of a return other than equities or property. This has been done to forestall recession. If there is a recession, the collapse will be very, very bad given there is not much room to further lower interest rates.
If you want to focus on these short-term, easily fixed tariffs, have at it. I'm going to continue to watch the leverage situation. I have to protect my money. The bubble and collapse with this much leverage building is not going to be pretty. I do not want to lose that much money. I expect to see another housing and equity collapse when this bubble pops. I can only hope it won't be as bad as 2008, but given the entire world is leveraged I don't see how it can be better.
Just remember what I told you about the leverage issue while you were worrying about short-term tariffs. And protect as much of your retirement assets as possible because I can't be sure how bad the next downturn will be. I think it will likely be a huge market hit and another property collapse, but hard to say.