Aseahawkfan wrote:Is the wide zone used by anyone else? Is it a good system in the modern NFL?
I don't watch a lot of other teams, but the Rams are the most notable. I've definitely seen the 9ers use it, but I couldn't tell you if it's their base scheme.
I prefer a gap scheme because it seems that there are more players that can thrive in that system and it won't collapse when key players get injured (and it's better in short yardage), but wide zone is definitely dynamic and can be a very good system. You know those plays against the Rams where they line up in 11 personnel and get 8 yards on a stretch run, and watching on the TV at home you're confused as hell because it seems like the Hawks had 7 in the box and a low safety and still couldn't stop the run? That's the wide zone. But you
have to have a back with great vision and one-cut explosiveness. I think Walker has the explosiveness, but I worry he doesn't have the vision for this system. And you obviously need the athletic linemen. In a gap scheme, you can often double to make up for a weak link. But it seems harder to me when you're moving laterally. When the DT knifes through, it's a big loss.
What I do like about the wide zone is that it's the best system out there for play-action pass. That system is what enables those naked bootlegs that McVay runs so well. Get the entire defense flowing to one side of the field and then peel the QB to the vacated space. It's really going to work well with Geno, who is obviously way more athletic than Stafford. With a good playcaller who doesn't abandon the run, this can neutralize (or at least dampen) the ability of an elite EDGE to take over a game. Either you run right at them and have the TE seal the outside or, when running away from them, they have to either commit to chasing the RB (and if they don't chase hard they'll never catch them) or they hold back to watch for the boot. So they'll often be in no-man's land. With an athletic QB like Geno, it will often be hard for the EDGE to stop the PA pass.