Aseahawkfan wrote:Robert Saleh is Lebanese. So that's why he wore the flag.
Jets owner is Woody Johnson, a Republican and a Trump supporter. Thus likely a very big supporter of Israel. Interesting to read on Woody Johnson. Now I see why he had little problem picking up Aaron Rodgers. At least he seems to keep mostly quiet about it.
Underperformance coupled with political beliefs not in line with owner likely main reason for firing.
River Dog wrote:The fact that Saleh is Lebanese is irrelevant. It was a very poor choice for him to show his political 'colors', so to speak, in lieu of his team's' colors and logo, which is what 95%+ of NFL head coaches wear on Game Day, especially considering the circumstances with what's going on in the Middle East. He brought on a controversy to the team that was completely unnecessary and avoidable. If that's why Johnson fired him, I don't have any problem with it whatsoever.
Admittedly this was a make-or-break season for Saleh, but the team's performance did not justify a firing. The Jets are 2-3 and a game out of first place in their division. They play the Bills next Monday night and will take over first place if they win. It's the first time in over 60 years that a coach with a .400 or better winning percentage has been fired in the first half of the season, and we're still 3 weeks until the halfway mark.
So really, there's only two possible reasons for the firing that make any sense: Expression of his political beliefs during a game or some type of locker room issue with the players.
Aseahawkfan wrote:Saleh wore the Lebanese flag because he is Lebanese ancestry. That is not irrelevant. It explains why he wore the flag. I have no idea if he had done this before and it had been allowed or if he did this as a political statement out of the blue. Often times someone has been doing something a while and no one notices until something happens like being fired. For all we know Saleh wore the Lebanese flag prior to this and it's only now being noted after his firing.
We can also be real: underperformance is what opened the door to his firing. You don't fire a winning coach for something like this, so the primary driver of his removal is underperformance.
River Dog wrote:After doing some research, I'll have to correct myself as I was in error. It turns out that Saleh wore the shirt/flag as part of the NFL's Heritage program:
Saleh was born in Michigan but is also of Lebanese descent. He was the first Muslim head coach in NFL history and is the fourth Arab-American head coach in history, joining Ed Khayat, Rich Kotite and Abe Gibron, all of whom are also of Lebanese descent. Both of Saleh's parents were born in Lebanon and emigrated to the United States ahead of his birth in 1979.
Saleh decided to wear the Lebanese flag on his arm during at least two NFL games as a nod to his heritage Saleh doesn't wear the flag every week, but he has worn the patch before. He did exactly that during a game last October. Some interpreted Saleh wearing the flag as a political statement. Fighting between Israel and Lebanon — in connection with the Israel-Palestine war — began weeks before Saleh wore the flag on his sleeve in 2023.
At the time, however, the NFL encouraged players and coaches to wear patches representing their heritage. Players added decals to the back of their helmets with their flags, while coaches added a patch to their team gear.
NFL executive vice president of club business, international and events Peter O'Reilly said the following regarding the initiative:.
https://www.sportingnews.com/ca/nfl/new ... 7e571fa29c
It would appear that the league had sanctioned such attire and Saleh was well right to wear it, so you can scratch that from the list of possible reasons he was fired so abruptly. But I still maintain that although he was in a make-or-break season, that the Jets 2-3 start was not the major reason he was fired. Something else has to have been at work.
Aseahawkfan wrote:Never heard of Saleh being some kind of cowboy like Colin K. So this makes more sense.
So underperformance likely cause and loss of locker room possible cause of underperformance, though I never believe in the locker room stuff myself. In my mind, professional players have to perform to keep their jobs. Football is optional and you don't ever want to become known as a locker room cancer as that can get you out of the league regardless of how good you are like we've seen with Percy Harvin or similar types of players. You gotta perform as every game and every week is measured by performance not only by your team, but by other teams who might possibly give you one of the rare million dollar a year plus NFL jobs. So there is no incentive to be a slacker in the NFL or not perform because the coach has lost the locker room as some purport.
If the Jets aren't performing they either lack the talent or the coach can't scheme the talent to put them in position to win, especially the ability to make adjustments to stop opponents attacking your schemes.
River Dog wrote:I don't know why Saleh was fired, but I can assure you that although the team's performance might have made for a good excuse, that it wasn't the root cause. They were 2-3 and one game out of first place in their division, not 0-5 and a laughingstock. They lost their last two games by a total of 7 points. They were not embarrassed. Owners don't fire their HC's in the first half of the season unless there's something else at work, like there was with Jion Gruden.
And speaking of locker room issues costing coaches their jobs, that's the reason why Jim Mora lasted just one season with us, because he lost the locker room.
River Dog wrote:I don't know why Saleh was fired, but I can assure you that although the team's performance might have made for a good excuse, that it wasn't the root cause. They were 2-3 and one game out of first place in their division, not 0-5 and a laughingstock. They lost their last two games by a total of 7 points. They were not embarrassed. Owners don't fire their HC's in the first half of the season unless there's something else at work, like there was with Jion Gruden.
And speaking of locker room issues costing coaches their jobs, that's the reason why Jim Mora lasted just one season with us, because he lost the locker room.
Aseahawkfan wrote:I don't believe that about Mora at all.
I think Paul Allen gave Tim Ruskell a shot to run the team. It was a disaster. He jettisoned Ruskell and his head coach Mora and brought in another high profile coach in Pete Carroll. This had been growing for some time as Ruskell used his power to force Holmgren out who despised Ruskell for losing Hutch costing him a major piece of his carefully constructed offense. When Allen decided to side with Ruskell and push Holmgren out, Ruskell was on a short leash and thus so was Mora. By the end of the season, Allen was done with Ruskell and thus done with Mora. He made his move and the rest is history.
The locker room had nothing to do with Mora being pushed out. Mora was hired by Ruskell and used as a pawn in a power struggle with Holmgren that Ruskell won. Ruskell victory was short lived and when Ruskell was pushed out, so was his pawn coach.
You were there Riverdog. You watched this stuff happen. How are you conflating Mora losing the locker room with his firing when you watched that BS power play by Ruskell against Holmgren play out? Mora was fired because the GM that hired him was no longer there to support him and the owner never wanted him to start with.
Uppercut wrote:There we go! If Hawks pay a Defensive Egg tomorrow they can hire Saleh as DC
NorthHawk wrote:I thought that comment was sarcasm.
Saleh comes from the Carroll tree and that’s a lot different schematically from MacDonald and Wink Martindales defenses.
Edit: If he gets back into coaching as an assistant coach it would probably be with SF.
NorthHawk wrote:On the Pat McAffee show, Rodgers said he was surprised by the firing.
Of course he wasn’t under oath or on a lie detector, but take it for what it’s worth.
The only offensive success Hackett has ever had in the NFL is when LaFleur in Green Bay called the plays.
He doesn’t seem to have done well as an OC and ply caller not to mention as a HC.
River Dog wrote:Believe what you want about Mora's firing. IMO he lost the locker room. You could see it on the field as the effort and enthusiasm wasn't there. The team had mailed it in. It was something we talked about in the old PI forum.
Aseahawkfan wrote:They didn't put Hackett in charge. Not sure what they're doing over there, but when you fire the head coach this early you're likely cooked for the season.
NorthHawk wrote:It seems the seat under Pederson is getting hotter with their most recent loss and Lawrence not playing well at QB. Has the team lost faith in their HC?
Jacksonville might just be the next make a HC change, but I'm not sure if Khan is the type to make that kind of change mid season.
NorthHawk wrote:Saints Dennis Allen is the next HC to be fired.
Poor record and we should have seen it coming.
NorthHawk wrote:Didn’t the Saints have a lousy record the last part of last year as well?
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 39 guests