RiverDog wrote:Oh, I agree, and I'm not saying that Goodwin is better than or even as close to being as good as DK. I'm just saying that it's a good demonstration of one of the reasons why wide receiver is down on my personal priority list when it comes to making a decision on who to draft or who to resign. There's some really good receivers out there that we haven't even heard of. Goodwin bounced around with 3 different teams before we got him. You can't say that about offensive tackles or edge rushers, at least not to the same degree.
I don't like to break the bank for any player as football is the ultimate team sport, but I do like one quality receiver with good chemistry with the QB. Seems that always helps a team. Then you can surround the core receiver with draft picks or moderately priced guys and do well enough. Right now Geno is so cheap, easy for us to afford DK and Tyler. Maybe not next year though. I get the feeling if Geno keeps up for the year, their might be a bidding war. Geno has to prove he can win from behind at least some of the time. Not many people will spend on a guy doing well for a year, but who can't get it done against playoff opponents in the fourth quarter with the game on the line.[/quote]
Again we gotta move the goalposts for Geno . Now it’s he can’t win a game in the end from behind . I’ll point out a few things one more time to dispell a myth like he can’t throw deep , dinks and dunks , Charlie check down.
As a rookie Geno Smith led the Nfl with 3 game winning drives . KJ lauded his 2 minute drill as one reason for his endorsement “ even if it’s Mayfield or Jimmy G. Mmmmmm. In his first start on the road vs Steelers and Watt he got us to overtime in the final seconds and damn near got in field goal range . Second start vs saints he drove the team in position for both a game tying and game winning Fg and meyers missed both . Atlanta ? Couldn’t convert 4th and 18 . Detroit he audibled to 2 Pennny TD runs including 3rd and 18. Scored 32 on saints should have been 40 plus . Last 2 ? After our screw up on the punt led to a 3 point margin Geno went 6-7 to drive the team into the red zone where he audibled to a Walker run to salt it away . I think he’s audibled into 4 or 5 TD runs .
Sunday ? You play like they did don’t have to worry about a lot of combacks.
Geno is capable of doing anything asked of him .