Page 1 of 1

Regrading the 2013 Draft

PostPosted: Thu May 05, 2016 9:21 am
by Oly
In the midst of all the talk of this year's draft, it's time to look at the most recent draft for which we can give grades: the 2013 draft.

Here is the class (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seattle_S ... 2013_draft):

Round Pick # Overall Name Position College
2 30 62 Christine Michael Running back Texas A&M
3 25 87 Jordan Hill Defensive tackle Penn State
4 26 123 Chris Harper Wide receiver Kansas State
5 4 137 Jesse Williams Defensive tackle Alabama
5 5 138 Tharold Simon Cornerback Louisiana State
5 25 158 Luke Willson Tight end Rice
6 26 194 Spencer Ware Running back Louisiana State
7 14 220 Ryan Seymour Guard Vanderbilt
7 25 231 Ty Powell Defensive end Harding
7 35 241 Jared Smith Defensive tackle New Hampshire
7 36 242 Michael Bowie Offensive tackle Northeastern State (OK)

A good reminder that JS/PC are human, after all. When the highlights are a rotational DT and a backup TE, you know it's a pretty terrible draft class.

The only question is if Bedard's grade of F- is too high: http://www.si.com/nfl/2016/05/05/nfl-dr ... is-results

Re: Regrading the 2013 Draft

PostPosted: Thu May 05, 2016 9:35 am
by NorthHawk
It wasn't good, but that class as a whole wasn't a stellar group to choose from.
I went down the list and there aren't very many standouts relative to the volume chosen, so I would think we weren't alone in a substandard result.
To add, it would have been very hard for someone to break into our lineup that year, anyway.

Re: Regrading the 2013 Draft

PostPosted: Thu May 05, 2016 10:14 am
by HumanCockroach
I don't know. Lot of guys on that list that are still in the NFL ( in fact most of them) none are stars, but quite a few have started games and had productive starts.

Re: Regrading the 2013 Draft

PostPosted: Thu May 05, 2016 11:22 am
by NorthHawk
HumanCockroach wrote:I don't know. Lot of guys on that list that are still in the NFL ( in fact most of them) none are stars, but quite a few have started games and had productive starts.


It looks to me that the value was the middle of the first until the middle of the 3rd round. The top of the draft was iffy with Joeckel and Fisher not yet being the studs the hype would have suggested by being top selections, but it picked up around the Sheldon Richardson pick. The QB class was stinko that year, and you are right there were some solid players, but it doesn't seem as deep as other drafts. Some teams that needed a lot of improvement at the time probably got the "glue" type of players that allow the stars to play better, though.

Re: Regrading the 2013 Draft

PostPosted: Thu May 05, 2016 11:24 am
by Oly
Maybe I'm too harsh, but to get zero starters (for the Hawks) and only a couple of role players from 11 picks seems really bad. The arguments about the quality of the entire 2013 draft class and the strength of our roster might convince me to move the grade up to an F+, but that's about it. :-)

Re: Regrading the 2013 Draft

PostPosted: Thu May 05, 2016 11:52 am
by NorthHawk
Oly wrote:Maybe I'm too harsh, but to get zero starters (for the Hawks) and only a couple of role players from 11 picks seems really bad. The arguments about the quality of the entire 2013 draft class and the strength of our roster might convince me to move the grade up to an F+, but that's about it. :-)


We were almost overloaded with talent, so if the pool of talent was in any way limited, it would be hard to find those that might break into the roster. We were clearly a young team on the rise that year, but if Jordan Hill had stayed healthy up to now, you might be looking at that draft a little differently.

Re: Regrading the 2013 Draft

PostPosted: Thu May 05, 2016 10:16 pm
by Zorn76
lol, I remember smh at the Michael pick, for sure.

'13 turned out to be an ok year, though:)

Re: Regrading the 2013 Draft

PostPosted: Fri May 06, 2016 6:23 am
by obiken
Zorn76 wrote:lol, I remember smh at the Michael pick, for sure.

'13 turned out to be an ok year, though:)


Sure but only because of the previous drafts.

Re: Regrading the 2013 Draft

PostPosted: Fri May 06, 2016 7:28 am
by c_hawkbob
obiken wrote:
Sure but only because of the previous drafts.


No one ever won the Super Bowl on the strength of that year's draft.